Tony's Conch Retreat Historic Old Town Key West: 834 Sq Ft, Two Full Baths, Walk Everywhere

$156-313/night
1 Bedroom • 2 Baths • Sleeps 1-2
Internet Near Ocean Downtown Pool (more...)

A one bedroom condo on the second floor of a historic house on William Street, right in Old Town. It takes the whole rear of the building end to end, which is how 834 square feet, high ceilings and two full bathrooms end up belonging to two people in the part of Key West where nobody has any room.

1 bedroom  ·  2 bathrooms  ·  Sleeps up to 2  ·  834 sq ft

The historic building is located within walking distance to the marina, Mallory Square and Duval Street just to name a few! The unit itself was so beautifully decorated and very comfortable.

4.92 from 13 reviews  ·  Valinda M, reviewed February 2025

Read all the reviews

Inside

One bedroom, two full bathrooms, and a den that closes off

The house is a conch house divided into five condos, and this is unit 5. Because it runs the full width of the back of the building, the rooms open into each other rather than off a corridor, and the ceilings are high enough that the whole place reads as larger than the square footage. The owner furnished it with original local art and a dining table and chairs custom made in specialty hardwoods.

  • Bedroom  King bed, with a real closet that takes hanging clothes and shelves rather than a rail behind a curtain
  • Two full bathrooms  Both full rather than one and a half, which is unusual in a one bedroom and means nobody is waiting on anybody
  • The den  Off the living room, with an antique desk, a comfortable chair, a small closet and a sleeper sofa. Accordion doors and curtains close it off completely when you want it to be its own room
  • Living and dining  High ceilings, a large foyer, a dining table seating six, a kitchen bar with two stools and a piano
  • Kitchen  Fully stocked, with a dishwasher, an ice maker, a blender and everything you need to cook properly rather than get by
  • Working from here  A desk and a desk chair in the den, and wifi at 500+ Mbps, which is why several guests book this one for a month at a time and work
  • Laundry  Washer and dryer in the unit

Outside

The covered balcony, the yard and the pool

  • Covered balcony  Off the back of the unit on the second floor, with seating and a deep overhang, looking down over the back yard and the pool. This is where guests say they spend the mornings
  • The pool  In the back yard, heated, shared with the other units and managed by the HOA. A pool at all is not a common thing in Old Town
  • Grill  By the pool, shared with the building
  • The yard  Lawn and garden behind the house, with the veranda and patio off it
  • Beach gear  Beach chairs, and beach and pool towels
  • Parking  There is none at all with this condo. Please read Good to know before you plan to bring a car

Location

William Street, Old Town Key West

William Street is in the historic district, and it is residential rather than commercial. That is the whole trick of this address. You are inside Old Town, on foot from the restaurants, the shops and the water, but the street itself is one where people live, so you are not sleeping above a bar. Several guests here have come back year after year and one couple stayed from May to November.

  • On foot  Old Town restaurants, the shops, the marina and the attractions
  • The house itself  A historic home on a quiet street in the historic district, converted into five condos
  • Beaches  Higgs Beach on Atlantic Boulevard, and Fort Zachary Taylor State Park
  • Groceries  Publix at Key Plaza and Winn Dixie on North Roosevelt Boulevard
  • Hospital  Lower Keys Medical Center on College Road

Good to know

This condo is on the second floor and a flight of stairs is the only way to it. There is no elevator, no ground floor room, and nothing we can do about either, because the building is historic. Everything you will use during your stay is at the top of those stairs. If anyone traveling with you cannot manage a staircase, this is the wrong property in our portfolio and we would far rather say so now than have you find out standing on the path with your bags. Several of our other homes have a bedroom and a bathroom on the entry level, and we will happily point you at them.

Sleeps up to 2 adults. This is a City of Key West occupancy limit rather than our preference, and it counts everyone staying. Two is the number whatever the bedroom, the den and the sofa might look like they could take.

There is no parking at this property. Not a driveway, not an assigned space, nothing. You park in a garage or find a non residential spot on the street, and a street spot has to be moved every three days or the car is ticketed. Plenty of guests here simply do without a car, because almost everything is walkable from the door.

28 night minimum, required by the City of Key West. This is a place for a month or a season, not a weekend.

The primary renter must be 30 or older. We also need the names and ages of everyone staying, which the City of Key West requires us to keep on record.

Key West has a noise ordinance and it applies to vacation rentals. No noise disturbance before 7am or dawn, whichever is earlier, and none after 10pm. It is a residential street and the rule is the city's, not ours.

No pets. This one is a condominium rule rather than the owner's decision, so there is no flexibility in it at all, however well behaved the dog is.

Check in is from 4pm and check out is by 10am.

Cancellation is a full refund if you cancel more than 60 days before arrival. Inside 60 days there is no refund.

No smoking anywhere in the condo.

Booking direct

You are talking to Meredith, not a call center

You are booking straight with Pineapple Properties of the Florida Keys rather than through a platform, so there is no booking fee on top and you can simply call. Meredith is a fifth generation Floridian, she manages these homes herself, and she is reachable by phone seven days a week. Before you arrive she emails the Welcome Letter with the address and your access details, and the door is keypad entry, so you let yourself in whatever time you get here.

Cancellation Policy: One hundred percent (100.00%) of the total booking charges will be refunded if the cancellation is made more than 60 days prior to the arrival date of the reservation. For cancellations made within 60 days prior to the arrival date, no refund will be issued.

Tony's Conch Retreat, #526, is managed by Meredith Tracy, Pineapple Properties of the Florida Keys. 407.733.2128. Direct Books welcome. Meredith is a Property Manager and owns Pineapple Properties of the Florida Keys. She is thrilled to represent the owners. Meredith is a fifth-generation native Floridian, Meredith's first visit to the Florida Keys was 35 years ago when she was 18 years old. She went sport fishing with the legendary Captain Skip Bradeen in Islamorada, explored the islands from Key Largo to Key West, and was hooked! Meredith, her husband Barry, a realtor, and their children enjoyed vacationing in the keys for many years and after raising their family in Winter Park, Florida, Barry and Meredith moved here full time! She loves helping guests with personal recommendations of all her favorite spots to help make their vacation better than they ever imagined!

Key West, Florida

Property Type Condo on the 2nd floor
Accommodation Entire Home
Check-In A keypad is available 24 hours a day to provide entry for guests
House Rules
  • Maximum occupancy: 2
  • Not suitable for children
  • Infants welcome
  • Smoking not allowed
  • Wheelchair inaccessible
  • Minimum age of primary renter: 30
  • Pets not allowed
Setting & View
  • Beach
  • Downtown
  • Near Ocean
General
  • Internet / Wifi
  • Air Conditioning
  • Central Heating
  • Linens Provided
  • Towels Provided
  • Washing Machine
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Hot Water
  • Private Living Room
  • Hair Dryer
  • Iron & Board
  • Ceiling Fans
  • Laptop Friendly Workspace
  • Basic Soaps
  • Paper Towels
  • Toilet Paper
  • Hangers
  • Private Entrance
  • Extra Pillows & Blankets
  • Clothing Storage (closet or wardrobe)
Kitchen
  • Kitchen
  • Refrigerator
  • Stove
  • Oven
  • Microwave
  • Dishwasher
  • Dishes & Utensils
  • Coffee Maker
  • Toaster
  • Ice Maker
  • Blender
  • Pots & Pans
  • Kitchen Island
  • Dining Table
  • Baking Sheet
  • Barbeque/Grill Utensils
  • Wine Glasses
Bathrooms 2 Baths
  • Full – Toilet
  • Full – Toilet
Sleeping Arrangements 1 Bedroom, sleeps 1-2
  • Master – 1 King Bed
  • Studio – 1 Sleeper Sofa
Entertainment
  • Television
  • Satellite/Cable
  • Books
  • Smart TV
Outdoor
  • Outdoor Grill
  • Deck/Patio (uncovered)
  • Balcony/Terrace
  • Lawn/Garden
  • Bicycles
  • Veranda
  • Beach Essentials
Pool/Spa
  • Communal Pool
Theme
  • Adventure
  • Historic
  • Romantic
  • Tourist Attractions
Attractions
  • Bay/Sound
  • Health/Beauty Spa
  • Marina
  • Museums
Leisure
  • Antiquing
  • Bird Watching
  • Eco Tourism
  • Paddle Boating
  • Boating
  • Shopping
  • Wildlife Viewing
  • Water Sports
Sports & Adventure
  • Cycling
  • Fishing
  • Golf
  • Jet Skiing
  • Kayaking
  • Parasailing
  • Sailing
  • Scuba Diving/Snorkeling
  • Water Skiing
  • Snorkeling
  • Swimming
Safety
  • Deadbolt Lock
  • Fire Extinguisher
  • Exterior Lighting
  • Smoke Detector
  • Enhanced Cleaning Practices
  • Cleaning Disinfection
  • Common Surface Disinfectant Cleaned
  • Linens High Temp Wash
Expectations
  • Requires Stairs
  • Potential Noise
Registration Number
D5404094/T54-8018179552-5